Key Takeaways
-
A new study suggests strength training may do more to ease symptoms of depression compared with other forms of exercise – particularly for people with mental health disorders.
-
Resistance training can help people achieve measurable goals, like completing more reps over time, which can boost confidence and hopefulness.
-
Like other exercise, it also promotes better sleep, healthy routines, and potentially even social connection.
Exercise has long been considered helpful for lifting mood and combating symptoms of depression, with cardiovascular exercises like running and swimming often considered most beneficial.
But new research suggests that one form of exercise has a slight edge over cardio: resistance training, commonly referred to as strength training.
“Depression can make you feel helpless and less confident in your ability to do things,” says Thea Gallagher, PsyD, a clinical associate professor at NYU Langone Health in New York City and cohost of the Mind in View podcast, who wasn’t involved in the new research. “Resistance training gives you something concrete to work toward: a movement that becomes easier, another repetition, a weight you couldn’t lift a few weeks ago. That can provide tangible evidence that your effort makes a difference.”
Resistance-Training Benefits Over Cardio Were Small, but Noticeable
For the new study, published in JAMA Network Open, researchers analyzed data from 80 randomized controlled trials that included more than 6,000 participants. Some studies were specifically focused on depression, but others recruited adults with other chronic health conditions. Some of the studies compared people who exercised with adults who were inactive.
Each trial involved at least three weeks of a single intervention, which included resistance training, cardio, relaxation techniques, flexibility exercises, and mind-body activities such as yoga. All participants answered questions about their mood and symptoms of depression at the beginning and the end of the trials.
Researchers found that resistance training had a slight but significant edge over all the other interventions (including doing nothing). Compared with cardio alone, strength training still had an edge, but the effect was small.
Strength training was also better at reducing depression symptoms for adults diagnosed with a mental health disorder than it was for adults without one.
Participants were more likely to report improved mood after resistance training if they were female and if they trained at least four times a week.
How Resistance Training May Provide a Lift, According to Experts
“Learning something new and seeing yourself improve can build confidence and feel empowering, particularly if you haven’t previously thought of yourself as someone who lifts weights,” says Caitlyn Mooney, MD, an orthopedic surgeon and assistant professor of orthopedic surgery at Vanderbilt University Medical Center in Nashville, Tennessee, who wasn’t involved in the new study.
As to why strength training may have an edge over cardio, “One possibility is that the measurable progress in resistance training creates a particularly strong sense of accomplishment,” Dr. Gallagher says. “For some people, feeling physically stronger may also improve confidence and how they feel about their bodies.”
But cardio can offer feelings of mastery, structure, and connection, too, she notes.
Any kind of structured exercise can influence how well a person can handle stress, Dr. Mooney says. “A regular exercise routine can also provide structure, opportunities for social connection, and better sleep,” she says. “The effect on mood likely comes from several factors working together.”
There Are Limitations to the Study
While the study found that resistance training may be more effective at influencing mood than cardio, Gallagher points out that the difference was slight.
“We shouldn’t take a small average difference and assume we know why it occurred, or that it will apply to every person,” Gallagher says. “The advantage over cardio was small, and only six trials specifically enrolled people with clinical depression,” she adds.
The researchers also flagged a lack of association between exercise intensity and antidepressant effects, which isn’t consistent with previous findings.
Finally, only about one-third of the trials continued beyond 12 weeks, with only one including adults with depression. That makes it hard to determine how resistance training impacts mental health in the long term.
“I would interpret this as good evidence to consider resistance training as part of a treatment plan, rather than evidence that everyone with depression should lift weights instead of doing cardio or receiving therapy or medication,” Gallagher says.
How to Incorporate Strength Training Into Your Routine
Experts suggest finding a resistance-training routine that works for you. “If someone is already feeling overwhelmed, I want the starting point to feel manageable,” Mooney says. “A few exercises on two days a week can be a practical beginning, with the challenge increasing gradually.”
Mooney also notes that resistance bands, light dumbbells, chair squats, and other bodyweight exercises are good places to start.
Eventually, a target should be to focus on resistance training two days a week, per physical activity guidelines, Gallagher says. “That is a general health recommendation, rather than a proven antidepressant dose from this study,” she says. “For someone experiencing depression, I’d focus first on establishing a realistic routine and gradually building it. If the plan feels overwhelming, make the first step smaller.”
Experts also stress that people who enjoy cardio should continue with it. “If walking, cycling, swimming, or dancing helps you feel better, keep doing it,” Mooney says.
“I would hate for someone to abandon an activity that helps them because they think they’re now doing the ‘wrong’ exercise for their mental health,” Gallagher says.
EDITORIAL SOURCES
Everyday Health follows strict sourcing guidelines to ensure the accuracy of its content, outlined in our editorial policy. We use only trustworthy sources, including peer-reviewed studies, board-certified medical experts, patients with lived experience, and information from top institutions.
Resources
-
O’Sullivan D et al. Resistance Exercise Training for Depressive Symptoms. JAMA Network Open. November 16, 2026.
Meet Our Experts
See Our Editorial Policy Meet Our Health Expert Network
Tom Gavin
Fact-Checker
Tom Gavin joined Everyday Health as copy chief in 2022 after a lengthy stint as a freelance copy editor. He has a bachelor’s degree in psychology from College of the Holy Cross.
Pri…
Korin Miller
Korin Miller
Author
Korin Miller is a health journalist with more than a decade of experience in the field. She covers a range of health topics, including nutrition, recent research, wellness, fitness…